AUDIO

by Phillip Jensen
Phillip Jensen speaks on Anger as part of a series on emotions in the Christian life, delivered at the Australia Day Convention 2010
LATEST COMMENTS
9 hours 42 minutes
Robert Denham commented on Hard Truth # 11: We must help each other more
Fighting the Taliban: lessons for mission
Michael Kellahan
March 31st, 2009

There is a massive disconnect between many churches and their parish. How do we change that? There are lessons to learn from the military’s counterinsurgency operations in Afghanistan (and Iraq). Company commanders are told their first task is to know their turf (or in our context - parish):

1. Know your turf. Know the people, the topography, economy, history, religion, and culture. Know every village, road, field, population group, tribal leader, and ancient grievance. Your task is to become the world expert on your district. If you don’t know precisely where you will be operating, study the general area. Read the map like a book: Study it every night before sleep and redraw it from memory every morning until you understand its patterns intuitively. Develop a mental model of your area, a framework in which to fit every new piece of knowledge you acquire. Study handover notes from predecessors; better still, get in touch with the unit in theater and pick their leaders’ brains. In an ideal world, intelligence officers and area experts would brief you; however, this rarely happens, and even if it does, there is no substitute for personal mastery. Understand the broader area of influence, which can be a wide area, particularly when insurgents draw on global grievances. Share out aspects of the operational area among platoon leaders and noncommissioned officers; have each individual develop a personal specialization and brief the others. Neglect this knowledge, and it will kill you. (taken from 28 Articles: Fundamentals of Company Level Counterinsurgency by David Kilcullen)

Putting aside the politics of counterterrorism, we can apply some of these lessons about tactical leadership to the mission field. Newly deployed rectors could aim for the following:


  1. be the world expert on your parish - what do the people there love and hate? where do they shop? are the local schools growing or contracting? what minority groups are there? Talk to lots of people - how has the area changed? where do people travel to work?

  2. recognise the local church as the front line of mission. Churches face complex, rapidly changing situations, that need tactical leadership. You need to work out what will work in your mission field - answers will not come from lifting templates from what others have done or by waiting for someone to tell you how to reach the people entrusted to your care.

  3. don’t hide in your Baghdad-style Green Zone! You need to get out and mix with people. It is easy to build church like a Fortress without any connection to the local area - you can even grow churches like that. But that is not the same as winning the hearts and minds of locals - and that must be your mission. They will not come to you unless you first go to them. 

Just to be clear: the analogy of war and ministry is banal if pushed too far - the differences are even more stark. But there are lessons here to learn.

Feature art courtesy of Wolfgang Wildner, Creative Commons licence

Steve Kryger    1 year, 4 months ago
Great article Michael, and helpful analogy. I think one of the challenges for churches is to be strategic in how they spend their time and resources. There's always more to do than can ever be done. I've realised with myself recently, that unless I plan something into my schedule (e.g. I'm trying to read more Christian books this year), it's not going to happen. Perhaps we could plan 2 hours a week/fortnight to go and chat to people in local shops and cafes.

#1 of 17 top
Richard Blight    1 year, 4 months ago
Hey Michael, you read some interesting stuff! I've long thought that the Principles of War have a great deal to teach us about effective ministry. Now it seems that 'counterinsurgency' may be a helpful analogy for the spiritual warfare we find ourselves in. There may be other poits to learn from - I like point 8 (with regard to counterinsugency specialists): "Rank is nothing: Talent is everything". . .

#2 of 17 top
Michael Kellahan    1 year, 4 months ago
@ Richard Yes, I'm thinking of doing a series on this on my blog. Some other lessons:
* one of the biggest problems the military faces is handover & short tours of duty compared to the length of counterinsurgency. We can have the same problem is rectors keep moving every few years - go early and stay long.
* another point of difference - we need to become local not just connect with locals.

#3 of 17 top
Michael Kellahan    1 year, 4 months ago
@ Steve - only 2 hours a week/fortnight?

#4 of 17 top
Brian Tung    1 year, 4 months ago
hey Michael, thanks for more good thoughts. I agree that there's lots to be learned from the military.
to add, I remember reading stuff from ex-military types who says that churches and coporations are too slow in making decisions. they feel that they need to know all the information before they can act. In the military, most of the time, in an operation they don't have that luxury. A decision is better than no decision (as long as you're willing to change).
the other thought is that a new rector can be like a young officer in command. Don't know much about the field and so need to rely on the expertise and experience of the non-commissioned offciers. I often wonder whether new rectors do this enough.

#5 of 17 top
Steve Kryger    1 year, 4 months ago
I thought 2 hours would be a good start! It's probably 2 hours more than some are doing (me included!)

#6 of 17 top
Michael Kellahan    1 year, 4 months ago
@ Brian - thanks. It is interesting that the original version of these 28 articles spread virally by email among middle ranking officers and NCOs. It was subsequently included in official training manuals etc. The web is enabling bottom up marketing of good ideas through relationships of influence.

#7 of 17 top
Michael Kellahan    1 year, 4 months ago
@ Steve - I don't want to get Pharisaic about it so don't hear me having a go. But I think we may need to free leaders up more than that. If you're in a small church (you're not - I am) why not spend a day a week doing evangelism? If one of the biggest problems we have is a disconnect between church and parish then leaders need to take the lead in getting out there - being missionaries to the parish. Do it with church members - meet at the cafe rather than church. Walk the streets and pray for them. Learn from the people who connect well with locals - in my experience they are usually the dog walkers.

#8 of 17 top
Steve Kryger    1 year, 4 months ago
These are great ideas Michael. I've also tried to build relationships with the cafes owners where I get my coffee. I think there's opportunities to sign up for courses at the neighbourhood centre. To wander the stalls at the local markets. To join the running club. Perhaps the ease of transport means that it's easy for us to spend time outside our community, rather than focusing in on it?

#9 of 17 top
Michael Kellahan    1 year, 4 months ago
@ Steve - yes ease of transport means people may work and play somewhere other than where they live. We need to respond by thinking about how we minister where people play and work.
But I think a bigger problem is the focus on church growth rather than engagement with the parish. Church growth may not represent kingdom growth within the parish at all - yet can take up so much of our time and energy. The analogy here is with the building up of enormous green zones that make people feel safe but serve to exclude locals. The better approach is to know the turf and get out there. And our locals mostly won't shoot at you;-)

#10 of 17 top
Phil Nicholson    1 year, 4 months ago
Great stuff here. I especially like the comments on the leaders being the ones out there on the streets.This ground work is essential if we are going to plant something with roots in the local community. In one of our church plants we sent in a couple 12 months ahead of the rest of the team just to do this sort of reconnaissance.

#11 of 17 top
Michael Canaris    1 year, 4 months ago
To back that article up with an analogy drawn from yet another field, one might note that a common community concern about modern police forces at times has been that they don't go 'on the beat' enough; instead finding that they tend to get snowed-under with petty-fogging paperwork at their office. Could similar pressures face your line of work?

#12 of 17 top
Michael Kellahan    1 year, 4 months ago
@ Phil - can you tell us more about what that 12 months involved? With so many around here talking about planting it would be great to here what they did & what the results of that were

#13 of 17 top
Michael Kellahan    1 year, 4 months ago
@ Michael - Yes, plenty of room for reform here although I think we need to look locally at what rector takes on in terms of admin before pointing finger at Anglican bureaucracy

#14 of 17 top
Phil Nicholson    1 year, 4 months ago
We planned to send a church planting team into a town in an area with a very low percentage of Christians. We sent one couple in first as other team members were getting ready (on furlough, language study.) The role of the first couple was research and networking. They were not expected to try to start a church initially in that year. They visited all the churches in the city & talked with the pastors to understand their goals and struggles and to explain what we had in mind so there would be a relationship established and no fear of sheep stealing. (We planned to focus on working class communities, the existing churches were all more middle class.) They also assisted some of these churches during the first year. I think this process was crucial in avoiding conflict and misunderstanding down the track.

They also did research on the town itself - where are the temples? what jobs do people do? where do people hang out? where do they shop? They met with local govt. officials, got a feel for the life of the town. Basically what your quote above suggested. So when the rest of the team came they already had an idea of where to live, how to meet people, where to rent an office, etc.

There is no need to just send in one couple first but it was helpful to have people with permission to just watch and make relationships without the pressure to immediately start something formal and then need to back-track later because they were in the wrong place or using the wrong approaches.

#15 of 17 top
Michael Kellahan    1 year, 4 months ago
Thanks Phil v helpful

#16 of 17 top
Michael Kellahan    1 year, 3 months ago
Someone who needs to remain anonymous wrote to me privately (but has permitted me to post this) about his Afganistan experience:
When you spend 18 waking hours a day living in the pockets of three hundred other people for months on end without a day off you develop a keen sense of what’s important and what is a petty, time-wasting distraction. Sharing a unity of purpose (with life and death implications for even the most basic decisions) mitigates self-centredness and pettiness. Why should a church community be any different? Surely we have a unity of purpose, and our message is all about life and death decisions. Yet we let ourselves get swamped by pettiness (too often disguised as championing doctrinal purity) and distracted by materialism and self-centredness. And I’m just as guilty of these things as anyone else
I am rebuked, challenged, and inspired by these insights

#17 of 17 top
Commenting is no longer available on this article.