P.S.

David, your concerns about Contemplative’s line of argument in this have some validity.

On re-reading this thread, this is a classic example of why Contemplative got into trouble for trolling. He has since left the forums in a melodramatic huff because we stopped regarding it as banter and saw it as being unhelpful trouble-making. You are just the latest to get sucked into thinking he wanted to debate matters rather that just stir the pot.